Hank's MGMT 649 Class blog
RSS icon Email icon Home icon
  • 5. Best Buy – China

    Posted on October 22nd, 2009 Hank 20 comments


    One month after Best Buy Inc. (Best Buy), the largest retailer of consumer electronics in the United States, acquired Five Star, the third-largest retailer of appliances and consumer electronics in China, in May 2006, the management of Best Buy is weighing its branding options. Should Best Buy retain the Five Star brand and let the two brands —  Five Star and Best Buy —  compete with each other in  the Chinese market? Or should Five Star lose its brand identity and be hereafter marketed as Best Buy?

    The options have a sense of déjà vu: when Best Buy first stepped out of its home  turf in January 2002, by acquiring Future  Shop, the largest  consumer electronics  retailer in Canada,  it had  been facing a  similar dilemma. The  company had decided, at  the time, in favor of  a dual-brand strategy, and had  thus retained Future  Shop  as a  brand  in  its  own right.  The  strategy  had  worked. There  had  been  no evidence  of  cannibalization —  the single  largest risk  in dual branding.  Both Best  Buy and  Future Shop  had grown  together as independent brands.

    Will the  dual-brand strategy  work  in China  for  Best Buy  with  regard  to Five  Star?  How should  the  company make it work? These questions are the focus of the case study.

    1. What are the conceptual underpinnings of a dual-brand strategy?
    2. What did Best Buy learn from its experience with dual-brand strategy in Canada?
    3. How does the Best Buy situation in China differ from its situation in Canada?
    4. Does a dual-brand strategy provide Best Buy with a core competitive advantage as it expands into new global markets?


    20 responses to “5. Best Buy – China”

    1. Team 10: Alonzo Perry, Jr. | Lei Song

      Team 5’s Best Buy in China presentation was thoughtful and well-executed. The team began with an overview of both the Best Buy and Five Star Brands companies, offered company background, prior decisions about expansion into the Canadian market, focused on Chinese economic conditions, and finally explained its choice to pursue dual branding in the new market along with recommendations for implementation. This blog comment will focus on the strengths of the team’s presentation style, in terms of design and delivery, and content and offer points of improvement for future projects.
      The PowerPoint slides used Best Buy’s iconic bright blue as a background as interchanged the yellow-tag motif with flags for each country that the retailer entered. The slides were organized neatly and the content was easy to understand. Overall, Team 5 did a great job presenting the Best Buy case. We appreciated that they focused on key learnings from Best Buy’s expansion into Canada as a basis for their analysis; Because of their attention to detail, the entire class was able to make informed opinions about the retailer’s branding options.

      Given the time constraints, Team 5 did a great job of covering an exhaustive list of Best Buy’s options given their decision to enter the Chinese market. We would have appreciated seeing some of the frameworks that we have covered in class. For instance, we used the value chain framework in our analysis. After seeing the differences in their value creation, we decided that the core competencies for the Five Star Brands companies and Best Buy were very different; such a large disparity in operating models could suffice as support for the company’s choice of dual branding, which both of our teams decided to pursue.

      The final part of the presentation was rife with information and was the most interesting part of the presentation. The team managed to touch on the pros and cons of each option, but we think that they should’ve monetized each of the options. Although we agree with the Team’s final decision, having a standard for evaluating each of the options would’ve made the presentation more effective. There were important considerations for each of the options (i.e. cannibalization of sales, no brand equity portability, zero competency transfer across retailers) and having importance weights or monetary estimations associated with each option could have enhanced the analysis.

      Ultimately, the most important consideration is that both Five Star Brands and Best Buy can survive because they’re offering the consumer two very different things: Best Buy is known for its customer service and offering a superior shopping experience while Five Star Brands is a predominantly vendor-staffed, low-cost alternative.

      We appreciated the team’s focus on the rise of the middle class (zhong chan) as a means of justification for entering the market. Relevant information about the sizable labor force and China’s fast-growing economy helped to frame the decision to expand the Best Buy brand.

      The video showcasing the store opening in China was a nice touch at the end of the presentation. It emphasized the importance of retaining the Five Star brand in the market while introducing Best Buy as a premium option in the market. Based on the video, Best Buy achieved great success and ended up pursuing an option that Team 5 supports.

    2. Hello team10 can I get the report of this Case…i need it…its really urgent…cn this be arranged?? if yeah…do send me on shilpagautam1@gmail.com


    3. Good bit

    4. For more of what you need to know visit this

    5. Keep the mixture cooled and pat it on your lips as often as necessary.
      With the growing trend of online shopping, more and more websites are emerging with quality hair care products for
      sleek and shiny hair. This is a review of this acne skincare line from this popular Tawainese skincare company.

      My webpage: medical Grade skin bleaching cream

    6. How many ways are there of going green in beauty schools.
      Adjust it one link at a time, flushing after each adjustment.
      Toilet paper is among the most essential product because you are always going to
      need it and you use it all the time.

      Here is my web site: install tub muvico pompano beach

    7. To help save money on energy bills, choose a model that turns
      off automatically as soon as the clothes are dry,
      and again, there is the option of rental finance if you can’t quite afford a dryer just yet.
      It has become the quintessential social event of any pre-game festivities and, what was originally an underground subculture,
      is now part of the mainstream sports atmosphere.
      But no one else will, even if the fix is not perfect.

      Feel free to surf to my weblog … dock box depot los angeles

    8. It records all the transactions taking place in a company so that you can always have a check on the losses if required and according to generally accepted accounting principles, the basic framework of accounting should always include finance and accounting records.

      6) Easy export and import:- A tax preparer can easily
      import W-2, Schedule D, Trial balance and Year-end balance, as well as
      forms like child’s form 8615 and K-1 data from 1041,
      1120S, and 1065 are easily exportable. Validation during
      - Data Import to ensure base data is correct resulting in generation of.

      My web site: charles brandon Fort Lauderdale CPAs

    9. In the first week, dieters consume six low-carb, protein-rich meals totaling 850 calories on weekdays and 1,200 calories on the weekends.
      The osmotic pressure will unnoticeably suck out toxins and unwanted
      fluids in the body. Quinoa seeds are coated with bitter
      tasting chemical compound called soponin that should be removed by thoroughly washing in water preferably twice.

      my web page; garcinia plus reviews

    10. Corporate Taxes: All business structures pay taxes on the income
      made in that particular business. Educating these customers in how to handle their tax affairs in the
      future can save them many thousands of dollars. For a common judgment creditor lien to outrank an IRS lien the lien needs to get recorded
      before the IRS’s lien is recorded, and be a “Choate” lien; which means
      it is a final lien circumstance, and that lien specifically lists what’s attached.

      Feel free to visit my blog post – Boca Raton CPA jobs in florida

    11. Overall, Amazon is a wonderful place for the best tanning creams at
      an extremely discounted rate to help you save some serious cash and get the products
      you really want. Third tip for removing self tanner is by using
      lemon juice mixed with kosher salt. Acting as a
      tan accelerator these lotions are great for achieving the perfect tan.

    12. These forms require you to have an employer identification number.
      Offer in Compromise: An Offer in Compromise is
      not an easy option to qualify for when you have Back IRS Taxes.

      For costs of home-based DUI, robbery and assault immigration-linked or another tricky New York Tax Attorney, New York Bankruptcy Attorney, New York Traffic Ticket
      Lawyer firm trouble, he promises to zealously promoter for your own interest.

      Check out my weblog … john costello Boca Raton CPAs

    13. It not only provides strength and improve the blood pressure
      by regulating the blood circulation, but also provides endurance and help with the overall immune system of the body.
      To get firmer arms, legs, and buttocks you’ll want to supplement, diet, as well as exercise.

      Delivery prices and times are of exceptional importance when running a

      Stop by my blog post; weight loss tips hcg

    14. Remember that your ex-girlfriend has moved on and no amount of sulking will make her come back so get up and get your life back.
      But also, the comments have affirmed that many are where I was before;
      in a place where they are putting on the happy face and
      hiding their fears from those around them. Providing assistance to customers who
      are trying to relocate is the responsibility of the customer service reps.

      my web page; moving and storage Containers by united mayflower promo code

    15. Everyone wants cheap bait these days but the big problem is that cheap often means rubbish.
      I have been using products from Newfields Baits for a while and their
      green lipped mussel extract is simply amazing.
      But have you ever thought about living in your boat full time.

      my web-site; dock small box latches

    16. This artificial fragrance, alcohols will create pain and skin irritation.
      Sun Labs also provides a lot of individual self tanning and fake
      tan products that you can sell to your clients as they walk out the door.

      Dark sunsation self tanning lotion is a perfect solution for immediate tanning needs.

      My homepage – professional spray tanning machines

    17. But the catch here is that you need to find a good hair transplant surgeon to
      do the job, if you really want good results. During the 20th century, labor began to change and
      more of it started to take place indoors. When you nourish the beauty within, you will also
      reflect that beauty outward to all you meet.

      my web blog; best spray tanning salons

    18. Many people advertise affiliate marketing as something that can be started for fairly cheap.
      com, or you’re planning to open one soon, it’s certain that some
      amount of homework will equip any crafter with improved knowledge of their unique niche, value,
      and target audience. Stick with the one that seems
      to have the greatest response.

      My weblog :: newport beach Marketing firm

    19. You will need to increase your water intake in order
      to keep your body very well hydrated. If this new discovery could actually drain fat cells and transform to positive natural energy, it might actually
      help people with obesity. Some of the fad diets which
      have been “the rage” over the past few decades include:

      Feel free to visit my blog post how Did Christina aguilera lose weight in 2013

    20. The B5 Regimen is a treatment plan that utilizes Vitamin B5 to cure acne.
      Don’t let yourself be baffled, acquiring benefits on the <. The best time to take a pregnancy test is in the morning when your levels of HCG are at their highest.

      Also visit my website – hcg
      diet Guide

    Leave a reply

    You can add images to your comment by clicking here.